Your Price Increase Communication Is Writing Their Counteroffer

I just got an auto-renewal notification for software I use a few times a year. Here’s what it said:

This is a reminder that your subscription will renew automatically on June 15th at $58.00.

Our standard pricing has increased over the years to support the new features and benefits provided in your plan. As a valued customer, you are receiving a 31% discount off our current pricing on your renewal.

You can manage your subscription from your account page. If you have any questions, please contact our Support Team.

Three smart things this company did:

  1. They didn’t tell me what I used to pay. No old price means no math. No math means no number to resent.
  2. They didn’t tell me specifically what percent increase this represents. That number, whatever it is, would have become the headline. They didn’t give it to me.
  3. The only number they gave me besides the new price was 31% off. The frame they handed me was a deal, not an increase.

I got the notification and moved on without a second thought.

Of course, a $58 annual spend is quite different from the hundreds of thousands of dollars one of your customers might spend with you. The dollar amounts are different, and your customers know what they’re spending. But how you frame a price increase still influences how much noise it makes. Choosing what to share isn’t the same as hiding something.

What Sellers Get Wrong

When sellers raise prices, they over-arm the customer. They open with the old price as “context.” They walk through the percentage. They justify it with inflation, input costs, value delivered, market conditions. They apologize. By the time the new number lands, the customer has a complete brief for the negotiation built by the seller.

Picture a rep walking into a customer meeting to announce a price increase.

  • Slide 1: a recap of the engagement with milestones, hours delivered, value summary.
  • Slide 2: last year’s price, the new price, and a callout showing the percentage increase.
  • Slides 3-5: cost justification, inflation data, investment in new features.
  • Slide 6: a “we value your partnership” close.

It doesn’t have to be a deck. Companies make the same mistakes in price increase letters. Regardless of the format, the instinct to overcommunicate is identical, and so is the damage.

Overcommunicating a price increase writes your customer’s negotiation strategy for them.

What to Do Instead

  1. Don’t volunteer the old price. If they ask, of course you’ll answer. But handing it over unprompted is handing them the argument. Given nothing to compare against, more customers than you think won’t go looking.
  2. Don’t calculate the increase for them. The percentage, the delta, the year-over-year math… none of it belongs in your communication unless they ask. Every number you volunteer is a number they can argue from.
  3. Lead with the favorable frame. If there’s a discount, open with the discount. If there’s a locked rate, lead with that. The first number the customer hears sets the anchor.

The software company sent me three sentences and highlighted a 31% discount. I have no idea what I used to pay. I have no idea what the increase was.  They have my business for another year.

Every piece of information in that email was chosen. So was everything they left out. Deliberate omission is a skill.

Transparency is a virtue. Volunteering ammunition is not.

Other Posts

Share the Boost blog!

Get the Boost Blog

Sign up to receive updates when new posts go live.